Millennial Skin

Toasty Makeup Is the Warm, Cozy Face I Keep Coming Back To

Toasty makeup is warm bronzer, a sun-flushed cheek, soft brown eyes and a glossy lip, all in one cozy color family. Here's how to get it, from a five-minute version to full glam.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Nothing on this page is sponsored.

Toasty makeup looks like you just came in from a long walk and stood next to a fireplace for a minute. Your cheeks are warm and your skin has a little bronze to it. Everything is blended so softly that nothing reads as a separate product. It’s cozy. It’s flattering. It works with a messy bun and a big sweater as well as it works with a slip dress.

This look took off on TikTok and keeps coming back, with plenty of new tutorials showing up right now. Bustle describes bronzer on the high points and a deep, almost sunburnt-looking blush. Lips go peach, brown or plum, often a brown liner with clear gloss. Who What Wear puts the feel in three colors: deep browns, burnt oranges and rusty reds.

If you already know my latte makeup guide, think of toasty as its warmer, softer cousin. Latte is about the bronze and the caramel lip. Toasty spreads the warmth across your whole face so your cheeks, eyes and lips all match. Here’s how I’d build it, from the lazy version to the dressed-up one.

What Is Toasty Makeup?

Toasty makeup is a warm, bronzed, softly blended look built on browns, burnt oranges and rusty reds. Makeup artist Lila Childs told Who What Wear she thinks of it as warm, ambient, slightly lived-in makeup without super clean, sharp lines.

It works on pretty much every skin tone, because you pick the depth of the bronzer and blush to match you. Fair skin leans peach and soft rust. Deeper skin looks great in copper and brick. The rule that stays the same for everyone is that every product sits in the same warm color family.

Start with skin that looks warm, not covered

View this post on Instagram

@chelseagehr / Instagram

NYC makeup artist Chelsea Gehr (@chelseagehr) told Elite Daily it’s about bringing soft, neutral warmth back into the skin. She keeps the finish hydrated and fresh rather than powdery or heavy. This is the everyday version I’d actually do on a Tuesday. Bronzy skin, a bit of color on the cheeks, mascara and a lip that looks like your lips, only better.

Prep matters more than coverage here. Moisturize first, then go sheer with foundation or skip it and just spot-conceal. Bustle suggests a brighter concealer under the eyes so the bronze around it really shows up.

For speed, a multiuse stick does most of the work. Physicians Formula’s Butter Glow & Go Multiuse Stick in Sunkissed Rose is made to stand in for bronzer, blush, eyeshadow and lip color. It glides on and blends into skin with your fingers, no brush needed. Mineral Fusion’s 3-in-1 Color Stick in Terra Cotta gives a sheer, shimmery peach to cheeks, lips and eyes. Swipe either one on, tap it in and you’re out the door.

Physicians Formula Butter Glow & Go Multiuse Stick, Sunkissed Rose

Physicians Formula Butter Glow & Go Multiuse Stick, Sunkissed Rose

One creamy stick for cheeks, eyes and lips with a radiant finish.

Shop

Mineral Fusion 3-in-1 Color Stick, Terra Cotta

Mineral Fusion 3-in-1 Color Stick, Terra Cotta

A sheer, shimmery peach for cheeks, lips and eyes.

Shop

Put bronzer where the sun would land

Physicians Formula product page for the Murumuru Butter Bronzer in the shade Bronzer, showing the swirled bronze powder in its green palm-leaf compact

Screenshot: Physicians Formula

Bronzer is the backbone of the whole look. Bustle’s placement is simple: cheekbones, temples, forehead and the bridge of the nose, basically anywhere the sun would hit first. Who What Wear adds one smart detail, which is taking the color a little wider than you would for a sunburn blush look. Use a big, fluffy brush and keep the edges soft.

I still think the Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer is one of the easiest drugstore picks for this. It’s a buttery powder with fine pearl and soft-focus pigments. You get a real bronze glow without the muddy, dirty look some powders leave behind. Physicians Formula calls it hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested, and it even comes with its own sponge.

Shade-wise, go one or two shades deeper than your skin, not five. Of the two shades here, Bronzer is lighter and Deep Bronzer is richer. Looking orange? You went too dark or too heavy, which a clean brush buffed over the top will soften right away.

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer, Bronzer

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer, Bronzer

A creamy-feel powder bronzer with fine pearl for a warm glow.

Shop

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer, Deep Bronzer

Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer, Deep Bronzer

The same formula in a richer shade for deeper skin tones.

Shop

Keep your cheeks, eyes and lips in one warm family

View this post on Instagram

@andrewdentonmakeup / Instagram

Celebrity makeup artist Andrew Denton (@andrewdentonmakeup) summed it up for Who What Wear. Toasty makeup is all about tonality, with every shade in the same warm family. His peachy, softly bronzed makeup on actor Elizabeth Dulau shows exactly what that means. Nothing fights, because cheeks, lids and lips all sit in that same rosy-brown range.

That’s also why the look is so forgiving. When everything is warm, a slightly heavy hand on the blush just blends into the bronzer. Who What Wear suggests matching your blush to your bronzer: copper with brick on deeper skin, rust with peach or apricot on fair skin.

On the eyes, cream sticks make this fast. Laura Mercier’s Caviar Stick Eye Shadow in Rosegold is a shimmery, long-wearing cream you can blend with a fingertip. For powder people, the ColourPop Nude Mood palette is nine warm browns and coppers. ILIA’s Multi-Stick in Dreamer, a terracotta, ties the cheeks and lips together. My favorite combo is the terracotta cheek with a camel coat and gold hoops.

ILIA Multi-Stick Cheek + Lip Color, Dreamer (Terracotta)

ILIA Multi-Stick Cheek + Lip Color, Dreamer (Terracotta)

A buildable terracotta cream for cheeks and lips.

Shop

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow Shimmer, Rosegold

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow Shimmer, Rosegold

A creamy, long-wearing shimmer stick that blends with a fingertip.

Shop

ColourPop Nude Mood Eyeshadow Palette

ColourPop Nude Mood Eyeshadow Palette

Nine warm browns and coppers in matte and metallic finishes.

Shop

Brown liner and gloss for the night-out version

View this post on Instagram

@lauren_damelio / Instagram

Want the full glam take? Look at Lauren D’Amelio Ventre (@lauren_damelio). She’s the celebrity and bridal makeup artist Bustle talked to about this trend. Her glam on @glamzilla has everything turned up a notch: smoky brown eyes, a warm flush and a glossy, brown-nude lip.

For the lip she layered a Fenty Beauty liner and a MAC liner with a Patrick Ta gloss and a Dior lipstick. She doesn’t name the exact shades she used. My closest pick for the liner is Fenty Beauty Trace’d Out Pencil Lip Liner in Brown’d Out, a rich brown. On top, I’d go with Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb in Hot Chocolit, a shimmery chocolate gloss. Her MAC and Patrick Ta picks are easiest to find on their own sites.

Line right on the edge of your lips or a hair outside it, smudge the liner inward with a fingertip and tap gloss over the center. It’s the most toasty part of the whole face. I’d wear this one with a black dress and pearl earrings.

Fenty Beauty Trace'd Out Pencil Lip Liner, Brown'd Out

Fenty Beauty Trace'd Out Pencil Lip Liner, Brown'd Out

A rich brown longwear liner to shape a warm lip.

Shop

Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb, Hot Chocolit

Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb, Hot Chocolit

A shimmery chocolate gloss to tap over brown liner.

Shop

Toasty makeup is the rare trend that’s both cozy and flattering, and you can even do the lazy version with one stick and a gloss. Which one are you trying first, the everyday face or the brown-liner glam?

How we pick

We read the ingredient list the way you would read a contract: closely, skeptically, and all the way to the fine print. Nobody pays for placement, and a product only makes a list if we would spend our own money on it again.