Millennial Skin

Burgundy Eye Makeup Is the Prettiest Break From Black Liner

Burgundy mascara, wine liner and soft smoky lids are everywhere right now. Here's how to wear burgundy eye makeup, from one coat of mascara to a full smoky eye.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Nothing on this page is sponsored.

Black eyeliner is the white T-shirt of makeup. It goes with everything and never lets you down. After a while, you stop noticing it at all. Burgundy is what happens when you swap that tee for a deep wine sweater. It’s the same easy routine, except suddenly people want to know what you did to your eyes.

Plenty of us are making the switch. Vogue Adria reports that interest in “burgundy mascara” is up 49 percent over the past three months, per global search data from the booking platform Fresha. Marie Claire just rounded up its favorite burgundy looks, and celebrity makeup artist Jenny Patinkin told E! News why brunettes in particular can’t get enough of it.

My favorite thing about this trend is how low-risk it is. You can do one coat of mascara and stop there, or build all the way up to a smoky wine eye for dinner. Here’s how I’d do each version.

Why Burgundy Flatters So Many Eye Colors

Burgundy isn’t one single shade. Patinkin told Marie Claire it’s a mix of red, brown and blue, which is why one tube can lean purple and the next can look almost brown. She likes a brown-based burgundy with a slightly cool tone and a little shimmer. MarQuis Ward, a celebrity makeup artist and educator for LYS Beauty, goes for a rich wine somewhere between deep red, plum and brown.

On brown eyes, it’s a softer frame than black. Patinkin calls it a good color for brunettes because it’s low contrast, and “a very sophisticated alternative to gray and black.” Makeup artist Lucy Hart told Who What Wear that burgundy liner especially suits green eyes, and blue eyes too. For picking a shade, Ward suggests rich berry, wine and oxblood tones with plum or brown undertones for deeper skin, and softer cranberry, muted wine and plum-based burgundies for lighter skin.

Watch Out for Redness

The one catch is redness. Patinkin warns that burgundy can be tricky if you have any redness around your eyes, especially on the inner rims, and a shade that leans too warm can make it stand out more. On the flip side, she says cooler tones on the lids can make the whites of your eyes look brighter.

So if your eyes tend to look pink by mid-afternoon, keep the color on your lids and lashes and skip the waterline. A plum-leaning burgundy is the easier pick for you too. If your eyes are red, itchy or irritated a lot, talk to your eye doctor before you start lining the waterline with anything.

Start with one coat of burgundy mascara

essence cosmetics product page photos of the Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara in Burgundy, a burgundy tube with its wand beside a burgundy mascara swatch

Screenshot: essence cosmetics

Mascara is the easiest way in. It’s where I’d tell almost everyone to start. Annabelle Taurua, a beauty expert at Fresha, told Vogue Adria it’s subtle enough to wear every day, just like your usual black or brown. From across the room, your lashes just look dark and soft. Up close, there’s a flash of wine.

Want more pop? Patinkin likes burgundy on its own for a tint, or swiped only on the tips over black for dimension. I’d do the tips trick on a workday, since your roots stay dark and defined and the color shows when you look up. Vogue Adria’s version is two coats with glowy skin, brushed-up brows and a berry lip balm.

Essence’s Lash Princess, which you probably already know, now comes in Burgundy, with the same cone-shaped fiber brush that fans lashes out. Maybelline’s Sky High in Burgundy Haze has the bendy Flex Tower brush and a washable formula with bamboo extract. My colored mascara guide covers the other shades if you get hooked.

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, Burgundy

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, Burgundy

A red-purple volumizing mascara with a cone-shaped fiber brush.

Shop

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara, Burgundy Haze

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara, Burgundy Haze

A lengthening burgundy mascara with a flexible brush and a washable formula.

Shop

Trade black liner for wine, or lean plum

View this post on Instagram

@mexicanbutjapanese / Instagram

Beauty creator @mexicanbutjapanese calls this a reverse purple-y smoky cat eye, and it shows how soft a colored liner can look. The plum sits along the lower lash line and kicks out at the corner. It frames the eye without the hard edge of a black wing. With a glossy pink lip, it reads polished rather than costume.

Hart’s method is simple. Smudge a pencil into the waterline, or glide it along the upper lash line and soften it with a brush. Who What Wear points out that pressing the color right into the roots of your upper lashes makes them look fuller. For night, Patinkin says a liquid burgundy cat eye works too. I love a smudgy wine line with a cream turtleneck and gold hoops.

Urban Decay’s 24/7 Liquid Stick in Wine Spill is a matte burgundy gel in a twist-up pencil. It has a slanted tip on one end and a blending brush on the other. For softer smudging, e.l.f.’s Smoky Kohl in Plum & Go is a pencil that smudges out fast. For a crisp wing, Maybelline’s Tattoo Studio Dip-Ink in Burgundy Boost has a felt tip and waterproof wear. Hooded lids? My eyeliner guide for hooded eyes helps with placement.

Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner, Wine Spill

Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner, Wine Spill

A matte burgundy gel liner with a slanted tip and a built-in blending brush.

Shop

e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner, Plum & Go

e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner, Plum & Go

A soft plum kohl pencil that blends and smudges easily.

Shop

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Dip-Ink Liquid Eyeliner, Burgundy Boost

Maybelline Tattoo Studio Dip-Ink Liquid Eyeliner, Burgundy Boost

A waterproof burgundy liquid liner with a felt tip for wings.

Shop

Wash the lid in a warm wine shade

View this post on Instagram

@marquiswardbeauty / Instagram

Celebrity makeup artist MarQuis Ward (@marquiswardbeauty) gave Ryan Destiny a soft smoky eye with a warm, reddish-brown crease and a lit-up lid. It isn’t loud at all, and that red in the brown makes her eyes look deeper and warmer than a plain brown shadow would.

Ward shared his formula for a monochrome burgundy eye with Marie Claire. He uses a matte burgundy through the crease and a warmer, more reflective one on the lid, then a deeper shade along the lash line. Three depths of one color keep it looking blended instead of bruised. Patinkin’s version is even easier: a sheer wash over the lid, built up at the outer corners.

A cream stick makes the wash almost foolproof. Charlotte Tilbury’s Exagger-Eyes stick in Bronzed Garnet is a shimmery garnet-bronze that’s waterproof and crease-proof. Swipe it on and blend it with a fingertip. For the crease and lash line, Milani’s Gilded Mini palette in The Wine Down has six mattes and shimmers from pink to deep wine.

Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-Eyes Easy Eyeshadow Stick, Bronzed Garnet

Charlotte Tilbury Exagger-Eyes Easy Eyeshadow Stick, Bronzed Garnet

A waterproof, crease-proof cream shadow stick in a warm garnet shimmer.

Shop

Milani Gilded Mini Eyeshadow Palette, The Wine Down

Milani Gilded Mini Eyeshadow Palette, The Wine Down

Six pink-to-wine mattes and shimmers in a pocket-size palette.

Shop

Go full smoky for a night out

Charlotte Tilbury tutorial photo of The Vintage Vamp look, a model with a smoky burgundy eye, full lashes and a deep berry lip against a dark red background

Screenshot: Charlotte Tilbury

Charlotte Tilbury’s Vintage Vamp look is the burgundy smoky eye at full volume, and it’s one of the prettiest versions out there. Its tutorial starts with an iridescent pink shade all over the lid. Next, a burgundy shade goes on in a V at the outer corner and gets blended up into the crease.

A plum shade deepens the outer corner and both lash lines. Then you tap a sparkly shade onto the center of the lid with a finger. A brown kohl liner flicked out at the end and black mascara on top and bottom lashes finish the eyes. If blending a smoky eye still feels tricky, my smoky eye guide walks through it.

The Luxury Palette in The Vintage Vamp has all four shades in one compact. Rock ‘N’ Kohl in Barbarella Brown is the creamy kohl from the tutorial, with a built-in smudger tip and waterproof wear. Marie Claire’s full burgundy face fits here too: pair it with a wine-stained lip and a little black dress.

Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette Eyeshadow Quad, The Vintage Vamp

Charlotte Tilbury Luxury Palette Eyeshadow Quad, The Vintage Vamp

Four shades for a prime, enhance, smoke and pop burgundy smoky eye.

Shop

Charlotte Tilbury Rock 'N' Kohl Eyeliner, Barbarella Brown

Charlotte Tilbury Rock 'N' Kohl Eyeliner, Barbarella Brown

A creamy waterproof kohl pencil with a built-in smudger tip.

Shop

If I could only pick one, it’s burgundy mascara on the tips over black. Which version are you trying first?

How we pick

We read the ingredient list the way you would read a contract: closely, skeptically, and all the way to the fine print. Nobody pays for placement, and a product only makes a list if we would spend our own money on it again.